NEWS: Free Music Ringtones For Verizon Isoetharine Metrizoate Federal direct student loan consolidation? First time home owner loan New home construction loan: Debt consolidation canada Kaolin Ceftizoxime Bad credit home loan mortgage se? Free Ringtones Samsung Sprint Application loan student Penbutolol Dont Eminem Know Ringtones? Us government student loan Sc student loan corporation: Antipyrine Loan nelnet student Atropine Maryland debt consolidation Home equity loan poor credit Delaware debt consolidation loan Tinzaparin Calan Debt consolidation plan Free Motorola Razr Ringtones! Glimepiride Alphaprodine Oregon home equity loan Naltrexone Azithromycin Maryland home equity loan. Unsecured personal loan Loprox! Kanamycin Imitrex Pyridostigmine Advance cash loan payday quick Bad credit florida home loan Equity florida home in loan. Butterfly Ringtones Androgel Cash loan payday Consolidation loan personal student Mosquito Npr Ringtones Debt consolidation loan online Canadian international loan program student Sildenafil! Free Sprint Sanyo Ringtones Debt consolidation online quote? Fast fax loan no payday Ringtones Converter Software Free Phone Real Ringtones Sprint Rifampin, Payday cash loan Glycopyrrolate Consolidation credit debt rating Consolidate defaulted loan student Pennsylvania home equity loan Calculator loan student: Online home improvement loan Federal student loan forgiveness Financing home loan mobile Cefepime Free Ringtones Converter Software New york home equity loan Consolidation debt free nonprofit Consolidate consolidation credit debt, Cerivastatin Canada cash in loan payday! Federal student loan forgiveness us loan mortgage, Ohio home equity loan rate Payday advance loan utah! Download Free Bollywood Ringtones Student loan people Home owner personal loan Ethotoin Free Lg Ringtones Verizon Vx3200 Wireless Sprint Cell Phone Ringtones Cellular Free Phone Ringtones Sprint Consolidation loan nelnet student? 1000 loan no payday telecheck Zalcitabine Lovastatin Penicillamine Fast private student loan Compare home loan mortgage new quote! Lamotrigine Furosemide Cheap payday loan Debt consolidation loan online Home improvement interest loan rate Private alternative student loan, Oregon debt consolidation loan Mosquito Npr Ringtones Misoprostol Home equity loan work Colesevelam Levorphanol Dexbrompheniramine Debt consolidation loan fast? Advance america payday loan Lexapro Bad credit home mortgage loan Quick personal loan? Ciguatoxin Cingular Mp3 Ringtones Secobarbital Uk personal loan online Download Ringtones Converter Nextel Ringtones Bank federal home loan pittsburgh Zyprexa Washington home loan Enebrel! Bad credit personal loan lender Home improvement loan uk Small personal loan bad credit Demeclocycline. Eprosartan Cash advance payday loan Accupril Tessalon Alphaprodine Downloadable Ringtones For Verizon Wireless Loan pay student Fast home equity loan Nialamide Methotrimeprazine Free debt consolidation program Home purchase loan rate Lynestrenol Federal student loan consolidation Free Polyphonic Ringtones Samsung Texas debt consolidation loan Prochlorperazine Bad credit home mortgage refinance loan, Benicar Great lake student loan, Home loan bad credit ok Motorola Tracfone Ringtones! Nokia 3360 Ringtones Antazoline Federal student loan Personal loan instant approval Sprint Download Ringtones Debt consolidation loan uk Chlorprothixene Adenosine Hydroflumethiazide Alternative student loan for bad credit Home loan mortgage new quote Fha mobile home loan Information loan student Personal loan agreement Home equity loan kentucky 6030 Nokia Ringtones Cefamandole Consolidation debt loan online uk. Atenolol Personal loan for non home owner High risk lender for a personal loan Calcifediol: Home savings and loan Refinance fha home loan! Clotrimazole Famciclovir First time home buyer fha loan Clonazepam Bad credit home mortgage loan quote Nortriptyline Ohio debt consolidation loan Quick payday advance loan Government home loan Alltel Downloadable Ringtones Average debt loan student Butalbital Guanadrel Consolidation debt uk? Fast home equity loan Clidinium En language loan payday Trientine Betamethasone Triazolam New home loan Buspirone New home mortgage loan Home loa loan mortgage refinance Broker california home loan Nutmeg Bill consolidation debt free Atenolol Consolidation debt loan uk unsecured Levoxyl Diazepam Consolidation debt loan non profit Zileuton Mobile home loan Card consolidation credit debt free Loan for non home owner, Credit card counseling debt consolidation Amiodarone Miami home equity loan Cash fast loan payday: Loan rate home equity loan Casanthranol No fax required payday loan Oleandomycin! New home construction loan Bad credit home loan texas Free debt consolidation services Best home equity loan California home loan mortgage refinance Dianabol Ambenonium Loan nz personal Avodart Free Cingular Ringtones For Motorola Phone Low interest rate personal loan Best refinance home mortgage loan rate, Free Ringtones Sanyo Sprint Debt consolidation home mortgage loan. Trichlormethiazide 125 home equity loan and second mortgage Debt consolidation loan online Amoxicillin? Federal home loan bank of new york Bad credit guaranteed loan personal Card consolidation credit debt management Hydroxychloroquine Clofibrate Free Cingular Wireless Ringtones Consumer credit debt consolidation First time home buyer loan Ethchlorvynol Personal loan to consolidate debt Cipro Texas home equity loan refinancing. Hydrochlorothiazide Best personal loan Cephapirin Mitoxantrone? Secured debt consolidation College consolidation debt loan Dianabol New home mortgage loan Zolpidem Remeron Dovonex Countrywide home inc loan: Free Nextel Phone Ringtones Phenindione Student loan debt consolidation Card consolidation credit debt free Centered christian consolidation debt Dalteparin Loan private student Lozol Metrizamide One hour payday loan Alltel Wireless Ringtones High risk unsecured personal loan Nelfinavir Alternative loan student Accutane Estrone Dopamine Debt consolidation new york: Primidone Debt consolidation loan calculator Consolidation direct federal loan student Mosquito Ringtones, Illinois home equity loan Reviparin Federal student loan program Home equity loan in florida! Great lake student loan consolidation Cyclophosphamide Protonix Home loan mortgage fha. Christian consolidation debt program Nitroprusside Home equity loan lowest rate Lansoprazole: Forgiveness loan student Consolidation debt fee free no Mexiletine Consolidation en language loan student Lomefloxacin Tegretol Electricity Famvir Amphetamine Cefadroxil: Hawaii home loan Interest only home loan Personal bank loan Christian debt consolidation loan. Thalidomide Boost Free Nextel Ringtones Home improvement loan interest rate Triamterene Nimodipine Colorado home mortgage loan Mosquito Pitch Ringtones Caller Indian Maxis Ringtones Nextel Ringtones Verizon Ringtones, Bank federal home loan seattle Free Ringtones For A Verizon Lg Vx3100 New orleans home loan Free Ringtones For Samsung Phone Homatropine Tampa home equity loan Home equity loan Home equity loan in california! Personal loan lender Personal loan in the uk? Credit card debt consolidation service Benadryl Card consolidation credit debt reduction Refinance loan for debt consolidation Indocin Easy personal loan Guaranteed unsecured personal loan Construction florida home loan Advance loan online payday Canadian debt consolidation Hetacillin Hexoprenaline Prazosin Bank home equity loan rate Losartan California home loan mortgage second southern Cell Cingular Free Phone Ringtones Subscription Without Bad credit student personal loan Uk unsecured personal loan Bactrim. Personal loan after bankruptcy Bromocriptine, Polyphonic Ringtones For Sony Ericsson Oxprenolol Nitrofurantoin Personal loan pay day loan Ceforanide Personal debt consolidation loan uk Consolidation interest loan rate student Milrinone Consolidation debt free information Tobramycin? 24 hour payday loan Pennsylvania debt consolidation loan, Cash loan student Claritin Florida home loan online Loan mae sallie student Caffeine Liothyronine Free Ringtones For Sprint Sanyo Phone Free Sprint Ringtones Consolidation credit debt loan poor Terbinafine! Best equity home loan quote Elidel Carbachol Meridia! Cosopt Mephenytoin? Payday loan Free Nextel Ringtones Divalproex Payday loan application? Debt consolidation Home equity loan utah? Medroxyprogesterone California equity home loan mortgage second Dobutamine Bank dallas federal home loan Home equity loan without perfect credit Home loan mortgage refinance mortgage Riboflavin Maprotiline Nitroglycerin Mirena Instant personal loan Consolidate loan student Consolidation federal loan program student Valsartan, Hexamethonium Free Verizon Ringtones Bad credit student personal loan Alaska loan student Celiprolol Dash Mobile Ringtones T: Hotlink Tamil Caller Ringtones Tricor, Estrogen Paxil Personal loan unsecured no credit check Dolasetron Consolidation loan student travel 50 Cent Free Ringtones Cytotec Alesse Debt consolidation lender Best unsecured personal loan Bad credit government home loan Ranitidine Second mortgage and home equity loan Carolina loan south student Carbinoxamine Clofazimine Las vegas home equity loan Va home mortgage loan rate: Mobile home refinance loan Consolidation credit debt rating Free Ringtones For Verizon Wireless Phone Home loan mortgage refinance loan Bendroflumethiazide Home loan cleveland ohio Tranylcypromine Allopurinol Nefazodone Minocin, Government debt consolidation Spiramycin Dance Last Ringtones Carbidopa Free Ringtones From Verizon Wireless Cyclizine Cell Mosquito Phone Ringtones Dactinomycin? Aspirin Chlordiazepoxide! Scopolamine Current home interest loan rate, Bankruptcy home improvement loan Free Pcs Ringtones Sprint Ondansetron California home equity loan: Bad credit personal signature loan Ipodate. Free Music Nextel Phone Ringtones Free Ringtones For Alltel Customer: Cheap home owner loan Free Music Nextel Ringtones Free Alltel Ringtones Methamphetamine Car loan for college student Auto fast loan payday California equity home in loan Low fee payday loan Loan home mortgage rate in california California home mortgage loan rate Bad credit need a personal loan New mexico home equity loan? Quinethazone Ativan! Lg Ringtones V111 Verizon Wireless California home loan refinancing Tricor 1 hour payday loan Consolidate consolidation credit debt Bad credit home loan va? Vytorin Ouabain Methacycline Free Ringtones Converter Software Free Real Ringtones For Boost Mobile Personal loan after bankruptcy Cell Free Phone Ringtones Wallpaper Personal loan application: Christian consolidation debt free Paregoric! Atlanta debt consolidation loan Dimenhydrinate Bromocriptine New home loan? Cingular Mp3 Ringtones Minnesota debt consolidation loan Oxycodone Delaware home equity loan. Flupenthixol Consolidation credit debt loan poor Colorado home loan mortgage refinance Bad credit home loan lender Podofilox Cogentin? Compare home equity loan Percocet Flurazepam Augmentin Tylenol Imiquimod Free T Mobile Real Music Ringtones Flunitrazepam! California home loan mortgage va Fixed rate home equity loan Aminoglutethimide Consolidate loan private student Phenyltoloxamine Mp3 Ringtones Converter, Epinephrine After bankruptcy home loan,

28.09.07 The Pigou Club Manifesto - Reloaded

We’ve missed the Second Pigou Club manifesto: here it is.

06.07.07 NY Times Editorial

NYTimes has joins Pigou Club with some wise words:

“Energy is currently underpriced in part because its cost does not
reflect the damage inflicted by fossil fuels. Underpricing leads to
overconsumption. Worse, it leads to underinvestment in alternatives. As
long as today’s energy is relatively cheap, there is little incentive
for private firms to develop new fuels and technologies.”

.. but also a reality check: “new taxes remain a political nonstarter, at least for now.”

03.04.07 Winners and Losers of Climate Change

New York Times has a nice graphical presentation of the cost distribution of climate change. It seems like the poor countries will be worst affected.

17.03.07 New York Times editorial

NYT has an editorial about limiting carbon outputs:

  • "But while technology will play an indispensable role, the lead authors of the M.I.T. report, writing in The Wall Street Journal, argue that the most effective way to reduce emissions is to attach a significant price to carbon emissions, either as a carbon tax or through a cap-and-trade program of the sort now embodied in various legislative proposals in Congress."

It seems that some of Pigou Club ideas are getting more and more popular .

13.02.07 David Friedman on Storms

David Friedman (Milton’s son) recently wrote a post about reality and hype in environmentalism. He found this image which shows that higher sea levels won’t endanger Manhattan by much in the event of a hurricane.

That is good news, but IPCC report also says:

  • It is more likely than not (>50%) that there has been some human contribution to the increases in hurricane intensity.
  • It is likely (>66%) that we will see increases in hurricane intensity during the 21st century.

Perhaps even the blue areas on that image will someday be partly attributed to global warming. The jury is still out on that one.

PS: David Friedman writes about economics of the World of Warcraft on his blog. If you would like to know more about market forces in computer games it is well worth reading.


“I’ll use this stick to measure the sea level..”

11.02.07 Different taxes different cars

Average European and US cars are quite different. The difference is mostly a consequence of higher gas taxes in Europe. The Economist has a nice chart in this week’s edition.

A huge difference indeed.

07.02.07 WWMS - What Would Milton Say?

One argument against Pigovian taxes was:

  • More important, on “Milton Friedman Day,” is my skepticism, noted in the post above, of empowering the government to choose the bad behavior that warrants a tax.

Another Pigou Club member Mike Moffatt found this quote from Free to Choose:

  • Private enterprises will bear all the cost only if they are required to pay for environmental damage. The way to do that is to impose effluent charges–not to have one government agency impose arbitrary standards and then set up another to cut through the first’s red tape.

It looks like Friedman was not a fan of CAFE and similar programs. He did seem to endorse Pigovian taxes in this case. In his book Capitalism and freedom Friedman writes about "neighborhood effects" as a justifiable reason for government intervention in free markets. He also mentions gas taxes as being relatively efficient. Friedman being Friedman also warns about the dangers of excessive intervention. Sadly, we cannot ask him what his opinion is, but I think he should not be considered an opponent of Pigou Club.

29.01.07 Another Look

Here is a statement that got me thinking:

  • The problem with "sin taxes," whether the sin is smoking, or not recycling, or driving to see Mom, is giving government the power to decide what sin is, what the wages of sin are, and who will pay.

Now hasn’t the government always been doing that? They decided that murder, theft and slander should be punished. In some countries sinning even includes flag burning, not wearing a seat belt or denying the holocaust. In USA sinning includes exposing minors to inapropriate images, while in other countries such incidents would be laughed off. So in essence:

  • Pigovian taxation is paying a sum of X for your sins.
  • Other sins are taxed by the formula Y*Z

Where Y is the chance of getting caught and Z is the punishment. It seems to me that every punishment (like getting a speeding ticket) is a form of Pigovian taxation. The difference is only in the chance of evading the tax. I wonder what Mr. Mankiw would say about this little theory.

29.01.07 NoPigou Strikes Back

I have to admit that my last post about wiggle room was not met with universal praise. Everyday Economist replied on his website:

  • The Pigou Club dismisses my argument by falsely assuming that their are no transaction or transition costs.

Not quite. In my post I just pointed out there is plenty of room for reducing gas consumption. Wikipedia also has this to say: The average fuel efficiency of European cars is over 40 mpg, Japanese cars 45 mpg, and North American cars 20.4 mpg. Do pigovian taxes create costs for the "sinners"? Of course they do, no one ever denied that. Another criticism comes from Three Sources, which starts off by saying that he has little respect for this site and continues:

  • I complained that the site was all but completely devoted to Global Warming.

I’m sorry about that, that seems to be the hottest topic on the menu. Oh and Mankiw’s Pigou Club manifesto starts with: With the midterm election around the corner, here’s a wacky idea you won’t often hear from our elected leaders: We should raise the tax on gasoline. The criticism continues:

  • …many people have a long term commitment on their transportation..

Again the manifesto comes in handy: I would like to see Congress increase the gas tax by $1 per gallon, phased in gradually by 10 cents per year over the next decade. Other complaints are more general and could be applied to taxation in general not just pigovian taxes.

28.01.07 Pigou Club Debunked

Everyday Economist debunks Pigou Club in his latest post:

  • Most people use their cars to drive to work, the store, and to see friends and family. If the tax on gasoline was raised, Mankiw argues, individuals would consume less. However, individuals would still have to go to work, pick up the groceries, and presumably visit with family. Thus there would be little wiggle room for reducing consumption.

Lets try to find some wiggle room
This cool Ford F-150 gets 13 miles per gallon

Wiggle room

 Toyota Prius gets 47 miles per gallon

Perhaps there is some room for improvement after all..